Comparative Analysis Of Public Pension System Economics Essay

the comparative research of the public and private insurance systems is of import as it provides fiscal benefits to the persons who have lost their income due to their old age and the resulting benefits are conditioned by the due parts ;

Anterior Work: this work continues old research conducted for the PhD thesis called “ Improving Management in the Public and Private Insurance Systems in the Market Economy ” ;

Approach: the chief methods that have been used in studies and observation of the population ‘s behavior ;

Consequences: in order to cut down the fiscal restraints that the public insurance system has to get by with, the concrete execution of a societal insurance system based on the demands and value graduated tables of the Rumanian province is necessary ;

Deductions: faculty members and research workers interested in the Rumanian societal insurance system direction and its long tally effects on the population ;

Value: the insurance systems determine the quality of life for most of the population and strongly act upon the economic system, particularly the labour market and the capital market. This is why societal security is a common challenge for all European states.

Keywords: Social Security ; Pay as You Go ; Retirement Pension

JEL Classification: Social Security and Public Pensions H55


Social security systems around the universe are in changeless version and reform so that they become financially feasible – taking into history several facets that have generated the crisis of these systems – altered economic and societal conditions in the universe, the happening or development of fiscal jobs on history of demographic tendencies and the political disadvantages caused by the generousness and / or high revenue enhancement. Assuming that societal security systems in most instances provide a minimal degree of protection, each state has decided – at certain phases – promoting private insurance, the single nest eggs by allowing revenue enhancement inducements in order to guarantee a higher grade of societal protection. After 21 old ages of economic and societal passage, Romania is still seeking difficult to construct a societal protection system to be sustainable in fiscal footings, and besides be feasible. In the old ages following 1989, the authoritiess of Romania have applied a comprehensive structural reform, which – together with the troubles inherent in any economic basicss – have exercised utmost fiscal force per unit area on the state ‘s societal protection system. So, defects of this system have been revealed, particularly in respect to pensions and other signifiers of societal insurance based on parts happening accordingly the demand for alteration, which consecutive authoritiess in power have approached it in different ways.

The inquiry is “ why do we necessitate private pensions? ” This phenomenon is caused chiefly by excessively little size of the societal security budget. Given that the figure of employees who work and pay societal security parts ( CAS ) has declined in recent old ages from 8.1 million in 1990 to 4, 8 1000000s in late June 2011 and the figure of taxpayers who sustain a pensionary ( dependent study ) decreased from 3.43 % in 1990 to approx. 0.8 in 2011, societal insurance budget is excessively low to supply nice pensions so that the buying power of pensionaries decreased by more than 50 % . Unfortunately, demographic tendencies and population migration phenomenon to other labour markets will be maintained in approaching old ages. We plan to analyse what can be done to cut down the instability.

1.1. Pension System in Romania

Romania has inherited from the Communist government a generous but disconnected and unsustainable pension system, which was based on mandatory parts paid by the insured throughout their working active life. Replacement rates were high and were paid a batch of many different types of retirement benefits ( including early retirement of normal age, subsister ‘s pension, shut-ins ‘ pension, pension for the handicapped ) . More over, authoritiess have funded and some benefits are non paid by parts from employees ( such as ill leave, pregnancy / kid rise uping leave, pensions for agricultural workers ) . Early old ages of passage were marked by ad hoc and hesitant reforms. As the passage progressed, pension strategy has suffered from several cardinal dazes, including a rapid addition in the figure of donees, as a effect of aging and generous programs dedicated to early retirement, combined with worsening economic growing and crisp lessening in the figure of remunerators to the pension financess every bit good as lifting unemployment and the figure of unregistered workers.

These jobs have become worse due to weak administrative capacity and policies that have encouraged early retirement and utilizing sickness pensions as a compensation for the increased unemployment rate of senior workers. Consequently, the dependence rate of the pension system has increased dramatically and continues to be presently one of the highest rates of dependence in Europe. Since the dependence ratio to aged population is expected continuously to turn, the demographic profile of Romania creates another beginning of concern for the grade of sustainability. This aging population procedure will make extra undertakings for every worker who should go on to back up a turning figure of pensionaries.

The authorities tried to get by with these restraints and jobs in keeping the high degree of parts to degrees that are considered really high even by OECD criterions. To counterbalance the diminution in grosss and increased disbursement of the system in the 1890ss, the rate of societal security parts increased from 14 % due to lodging associations and 15 % of concern units ( Ghimpu S. & A ; Al, 1982, p.290-291 ) to 35 % in 2001. Although the rate was lowered to 29.75 % in January 2006 is presently 31.3 % harmonizing to Budget Law on State Social Security 2011 and consequently to international criterions, continues to be high. Furthermore, the entire societal security outgo ( pensions, wellness, unemployment, work hurt and disablement ) amounts to about 50 % of gross wage, therefore transforming the Rumanian work force in one of the hardest taxed in Central and Eastern Europe.

1.2. Social Security System state of affairs in other European states

Romania – with parts numbering 46.25 % from wages, ranks 6 ( from 26 states ) in Europe in footings of societal security parts, together with Albania ( 49 % ) , Poland ( 46.64 % ) and Hungary ( 45.50 % ) , which is on the prima topographic points among the states of Central and Eastern Europe. Even wage-related parts collectible in Italy, considered burdensome by OECD criterions, is much lower than what is charged in Romania. These important parts increase labour costs for non-professional activities and can hold inauspicious effects on legitimate occupation creative activity every bit good as, by extension, on the possibilities to back up the pension granted by the province budget.

1.3. Pension costs in Romania

Equally long as it erodes the footing of part to pension program in which parts are paid during working life, procedure which should be accompanied by increasing its grade of fiscal sustainability, it is confronting a turning hazard, happening a relentless systemic lack. State Social Security budget declined steadily – from more than 1.1 % of GDP in 1991 to a shortage of 0.85 % of GDP in 2003. Sing that public disbursement on societal insurance plans was ever higher, making up to 6.7 % in 2003, this has merely served to further increase the pension revenue enhancement load on general budget. Since 2003, passing on pensions fell to 6.3 % of GDP, recorded value in 2005, chiefly as a consequence of switching the funding of pensions for workers in agribusiness that is non based on their old parts, from general grosss to the province budget chapter. Long-run projections made by the World Bank suggest a stabilisation of disbursals aˆ‹aˆ‹to a value of about 6 % of GDP ( World Bank, 1994 ) .

Allianz Demographic Pulse survey on the planetary phenomenon of increasing population age-related costs, pensions and wellness services in our state is anticipated that most disbursement on pensions will increase by over 9 per centum points of GDP over a period of about 50 old ages – from 6.6 % of GDP in 2007 to about 15.8 % of GDP in 2060. Furthermore, by conventional steps dwelling of inexplicit pension debt ( DIP ) , the contingent liabilities of the pension strategy from the province budget systems in Romania exceeded most of its neighbours every bit good as those in many OECD states. Although no comparative recent information exists, international ranking of Romania depending contingent liabilities of the pension system continues to stay a concern. State Social Security budget recorded in the first 5 months of 2010 a shortage of 4.15 billion wreath ( General Budget, 2010, p. 2 ) , about one billion euros, up to 59 % over the same period of 2009, harmonizing to informations published by the Ministry of Finance.

To income about equal ( 13.6 billion wreath ) in 5 months 2010 ( Statistical Indicators Pillar I, 2010 ) and 5 months 2009 ( Statistical Indicators Pillar I, 2009 ) , the public pension budget saw higher disbursement by about 9 % , caused by the addition of pensions by 5 % in 2009 and the moving ridge of early retirements in the period before the acceptance of new pension jurisprudence. Number of retirement, particularly early and disablement, has greatly increased, people being afraid of new conditions, more restrictive, for early retirement in the new pension jurisprudence so that the outgo to the State Social Security budget reached 42.64 billion wreaths, intending 8.33 % of GDP at the terminal of 2010. In the first five months of 2010, public pension budget shortage represented 30.6 % of grosss that is a subtraction already dismaying for a short-run fiscal sustainability of the system.

Following a 25 % decrease of all wages budget for 2010 it was reduced practically the degree paid to CAS pension budget. Under these fortunes, it was expected an increasing growing rate of the shortage to the terminal. To cover the shortage were allocated grants from the province general authorities worth 10.95 billion wreaths harmonizing to informations published by the Ministry of Finance.

1.4. Measures taken to guarantee the fiscal sustainability of the Pension System in Romania

Since 2004 authoritiess have started implementing an ambitious program of consolidation but – despite the registered success aˆ‹aˆ‹regarding the commanding pension costs – long-run fiscal sustainability is still unsure. The chief steps that were introduced including the transportation of benefits that are non fed from old parts outside the National House of Pensions, to other fiscal beginnings: raising the retirement age to 60 old ages for adult females and 65 for work forces ; increasing the part period from 10 to 15 old ages, while the entire part period reached 30 old ages for adult females and 35 work forces, 5 old ages longer than earlier ; decreases in the spread between the retirement age of work forces and adult females ; gradual lessening the degree of parts and presenting a new mechanism to to the full index these benefits against rising prices.

1.5. Desideratum to construct an appropriate and sustainable

Pension System in Romania

Although viability of the fiscal payment to Social Security budget system during the active life ( pay-as-you-go ) is improved following recent reforms of the system, it still fails of accomplishing fiscal sustainability. There are excessively many chances for discretional action by politicians that makes any actuarial projection medium and long term to be unsure. In add-on to low retirement ages, a menace to the sustainability of the pension system was the pattern of re-correlation. Sing that faced with an eroding of the existent value of pensions, pensionaries have asked for a readjustment of their pensions to a similar degree that accorded to new retired persons, which basically is an ad-hoc indexation of the rewards. Although re-correlation ought to use merely to those who retired before 1999 full length and their subsisters, it was expanded to new classs of pensionaries. This occurred as a series of discretional actions ensuing from political lobbying, instead than any formal policy or profit adjustment predictable regulations.

Lack of clear regulations of indexation benefits or deficiency of a systematic attack to correlativity makes the pension system highly vulnerable, practical “ inviting ” exercise political force per unit area from all groups who need support ( Ghinararu, C, 2006 ) . This increases the hazard of the system to fall back into a barbarous circle of ad-hoc determinations, designed to protect certain political involvements, which could take to complete failure of system, particularly given that the regulations for finding benefits are excessively flexible due to tonss that are mistily defined. The consequence gives an unneeded uncertainness for all participants in the pension program, and the state ‘s financial mentality.

In add-on, pension program paid by the province budget in Romania continues to be affected by major structural failings and imposes a high part rate exciting equivocation, cut downing the part base. Sing the low retirement age and equivocation, the system still suffers from high dependance on the overall system. The combined consequence of high revenue enhancements on wages is made of labour productiveness minimizing and experient labour hiring, and hence a decrease in GDP. Therefore, the pension system non merely can non supply safety for the aged in a sustainable and just manner, but besides harms the economic system. Of class, although diminishing part rates may assist to cut down economic deformations ; related public policy would hold an immediate impact on the fiscal facets of pensions from the province budget, which are already unstable.

In 2004 the Government approved the Torahs on the compulsory private pension pillars voluntarily administrated, after consecutive authoritiess in the state ‘s leading have ever proposed to present private pension strategies. Plan debut of Pillar II consisting of compelled private pensions needed deviating a part of the needed parts from the public pillar, get downing with a mark of 2 % of current parts in 2008 and so bit by bit increasing an extra half a per centum point each twelvemonth by 2016, the part to the private pillar will make six per centum points. The cost of this passage – debaring a portion of grosss to the budget from public pillar, which will go on paying benefits for the aged and which will be capable of claims made aˆ‹aˆ‹by those who are presently employed – is expected to be little at first, but will increase over clip. The mean one-year cost of this passage, supported by the authorities in 2007-2011, is 0.3 % of GDP. Equally long as the sum of parts diverted to funded strategies additions, the cost of passage will be greater, taking to an one-year norm of 0.7 % of GDP in the period 2012 -2017 and runing between 0.5 % and 0.8 % of GDP thereafter. However, with the part rate decreases, which are considered every bit good as future additions in benefits, which are besides considered ; this passage will add a fiscal strain on the already delicate balance of the public pension pillar. When it began roll uping parts for compulsory pension strategies, the capital market in Romania has faced dashing challenge to increase the flow of safe domestic securities that can be traded at a set monetary value in an effectual manner. The absence of necessary and compulsory regulative demands, a information and financial direction for private pension programs have ever delayed the creative activity of these instruments.

Similarly to other states in Central and Eastern Europe, European fiscal markets are dominated by Bankss, sedimentations being up over 80 % of entire fiscal assets. However, the volume of fiscal assets is about half of that observed in other states being in accession, reflecting the low per capita income and low assurance in fiscal establishments. Companies are financed by Bankss, without trusting on the equity or bond issues.

Insurance assets – as a per centum of GDP – were at 1.45 % ( in 2004 ) with life insurance premiums stand foring merely 0.34 % . Common financess accounted for merely 0.2 % of GDP. The two chief exchanges – BSE and RASDAQ – at that clip had a market capitalisation of about 12 % of GDP and a net income rate of 11 % . Both indexs fall good below those recorded in Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic, are less than found in Bulgaria and Croatia ( Social Protection Committee, 2004 ) . Market concentration is besides high, with the largest 5 companies stand foring 75 % of capitalisation. Developing the fiscal sector and capital market continues to be hampered by discretion and misgiving of persons every bit good as by fiscal mediators. In the yesteryear, developments in capital markets has been hampered by misgiving that the populace had for non-bank fiscal mediators, misgiving has been fueled by assorted dirts and bankruptcies, which caused losingss to investors. Corporate administration is non up to the necessary degree neither in state-owned companies nor in private companies. Besides, the judicial system can non turn to belongings judicial proceeding and commercial differences merely with long holds, which undermine investor assurance and standardised contracts application. In general, the accounting ordinances are in conformity to the International Accounting Standards, although there are still differences. Regulations on enrollment in the histories are unsatisfactory, doing it hard for investors to roll up relevant information, accurate and timely information on issuers. A funded pension pillar would non be based on a robust capital market, but it must work as a tool for capital market development. It remains to be seen whether such an outlook is realistic, given the current state of affairs in Romania, it is the outlook that structural pension reforms could spread out and diversify its markets, unrealized outlooks in any of states in the part, whose developing fiscal sectors have introduced private pension programs.

“ In 2010, 2 old ages after the execution of Pillar II and 3 old ages after the first parts to Pillar III, we can already speak about consequences. Measurable consequences in existent benefits for the participants and highlighted in the single histories net income for private pensions. Besides we speak of consequences expressed by a better organisation of the system, in footings of legal and functional, “ said Mircea Oancea, President of CSSPP, the message opening CSSPP Report for 2010 ( study CSSPP, 2010, p.8 ) .

1.6. Decisions on policies to better System of

Pensions in Romania

Since 2004, the Rumanian authorities has implemented several hard parametric reforms but – nevertheless – there is still much to make for the public pension pillar can be put in a solid place. Some reforms, such as diminishing part rates, the riddance of short-run benefits that are non paid based on their parts and pensions paid to agricultural workers under the old pension plan in agribusiness were predicted and were considered when the projections were made to finance those plans. Tightening the standard for medical rating had some consequence in decreasing disablement pensions. However, replacing rates for disablement pensions or subsisters ‘ pensions are low and subsisters ‘ pensions were diminished anyhow to some extent in recent old ages. Therefore, it is necessary to do a more profound rating of plans dedicated to disenable and survivor pension donees. No other anticipated alterations were made, including faster growing of retirement ages and equalising the retirement ages of work forces and adult females. While – since 2006 – the authorities has made one-year rising prices accommodations for benefits, these additions were much higher than rising prices. Furthermore, discretional benefit accommodations made aˆ‹aˆ‹under political force per unit area continues today. Presently, the net consequence of steps taken since 2004 has been to equilibrate the support. However, medium-term fiscal state of affairs of the public pillar should be more closely evaluated and projections should besides be made aˆ‹aˆ‹on a figure of different scenarios. Harmonizing to authorities estimations, the combined costs of passage are hard to be accurately projected and experiences from other states ( Hungary, Poland, and Slovakia, among others ) are relevant in this regard, it is of import that these costs are sporadically reviewed and their relevancy should be followed carefully. A private pension regulative system was established, but needs to be strengthened. A strong regulative factor, professional and good fit it is indispensable to the success of a new market for the proviso of contractual nest eggs, voluntary or compulsory. However, when presenting a new market for compulsory contractual nest eggs, good drawn ordinances are even more of import, non merely for system dependability, but besides to guarantee competition among private suppliers of fiscal services. Status of capital market development and fiscal sector in Romania engages the necessity that factors who elaborate policies to pay a particular attending to market construction and investing ordinance. It is really possible that pension financess in Romania to maintain its assets in securities of the province – particularly exchequers measures and bonds maturating short to medium term – sedimentations and fixed income instruments – such as mortgage bonds which are issued by Bankss.

Here are some specific proposals originating from the treatment above:

aˆ? Increasing the retirement age – current agenda for increasing the standard retirement age should be accelerated and standard retirement age for work forces and adult females should be equalized every bit shortly as possible ;

aˆ? Increasing the index between retirement age and that of life anticipation – the authorities needs to determine and research the option of increasing the retirement age in line with increasing life anticipation ;

aˆ? Evaluation of disablement allowances – should be performed in the manner of fastening the conditions of eligibility for disablement pensions, followed by execution of relevant steps ;

aˆ? Researching the viability of basic pension ( “ Zero Pillar ” ) in the current Social Assistance Package. This pillar, known as the basic pillar is designed to be able to turn to more efficaciously the people who are hapless throughout their lives, every bit good as undocumented workers and making old age without sufficient resources or they are non eligible for a pension consequently to jurisprudence. This benefit will replace the minimal income for hapless people above retirement age and who must be financed from the province budget ;

aˆ? Develop a public instruction scheme – with the execution of compulsory private pillar, it had to develop and implement a well defined public instruction scheme in order to raise consciousness among the populace of these of import structural alterations.


The passage to market economic system involves work outing many jobs, one of the most terrible being the support of public pensions. It required a alteration in people ‘s perceptual experience of these jobs: they must foremost be recognized and so cover with straight.

Without indispensable and deep alterations in perceptual experience and economic thought manner, it is impossible crystallisation of a echt market economic system in Romania. For now, we go through passage but the strongest feeling is that of instability, which reflects on all those involved in the game market.

The research summarized in this survey unfastened new lines of attack. Problems are non solved and I suggest – for the hereafter – to intensify the topic and related research subjects such as: the consequence of cut downing employees through layoffs, the perceptual experience of standards of taking a agent of insurance, educational theoretical accounts for the perceptual experience of young person on pension as an changeless world.